Tim Cerio, chief executive of Florida’s state-created Citizens Property Insurance Corp., will leave the insurer in January to return to the private sector, ending a tenure that spanned a sharp reversal in the company’s size. Cerio told staff on Friday, Nov. 20, that he would depart after nearly four years as president and CEO and executive director. He did not say what work he plans to pursue, and Citizens has not identified a successor.
A transition plan is still taking shape
Cerio said he would work with Citizens’ Board of Governors over the coming weeks on a transition plan, with further details to come. The announcement therefore sets a departure timeframe but leaves key questions open, including who will lead the insurer next and how the board will manage the handover. No replacement has been announced, and the company has not described a search process or a timetable for naming a successor.
The change comes as Citizens continues to manage a much smaller policy base than it did at the height of Florida’s property insurance turmoil. Cerio became CEO in January 2023, succeeding Barry Gilway, who retired. Before that appointment, Cerio had served as Citizens’ general counsel in 2015 and 2016. He is a lawyer and a University of Florida graduate, with both a bachelor’s degree and a law degree from the university.
Citizens has contracted after a record expansion
Cerio took charge as private insurers faced severe pressure in Florida. Ten carriers became insolvent during the wider crisis, while rates rose and many homeowners moved to Citizens. The state-created insurer has statutory limits on premium increases, making it an important option for policyholders who had difficulty finding or keeping private coverage. By September 2023, Citizens had more than 1.4 million policies, making it Florida’s largest property insurer by a wide margin.
That surge was followed by a sustained contraction. Citizens reported 216,447 policies in force at the end of October 2026, its lowest level in more than 20 years, according to the source report. Cerio credited legislative changes adopted in 2022 and 2023 with giving the organization tools to change course, particularly reforms aimed at curbing claims litigation. He also emphasized that legislation alone did not produce the results, pointing to the work of the organization and its staff.
The policy count is a notable measure of how quickly Citizens’ role has shifted: from absorbing large numbers of policies during a period of carrier failures to reducing its exposure as conditions changed. The figures do not, by themselves, explain the circumstances of individual policyholders or the financial position of the wider market. They do show the scale of the operational challenge Citizens has faced in both directions, first accommodating rapid growth and then adapting to a substantially smaller organization.
Leadership handover follows organizational change
Cerio said Citizens had become more focused while maintaining financial discipline and readiness. He also described the work of shrinking the organization as difficult, noting that employees had taken on new responsibilities, adjusted to changing processes and supported colleagues through transitions. His comments point to an internal task alongside the shift in policy volume: keeping the insurer functioning as its staffing and operational needs change. The company has not provided specific details about employee numbers or further organizational changes.
Citizens Board Chairman Carlos Beruff praised Cerio’s leadership, describing him as a steady leader during a critical period for Florida’s property insurance market. Beruff said Cerio leaves the insurer stronger and better positioned for the future, and thanked him for his public service. Cerio is also set to continue serving on Governor-elect Byron Donalds’ transition team and as vice chairman of the Board of Governors of the State University System, according to Citizens’ announcement.
For policyholders, insurance agents and businesses that rely on Florida property coverage, the immediate development is a change in leadership at an insurer whose footprint has moved dramatically in recent years. The pending handover makes continuity and the board’s eventual choice of a successor important areas to watch, but Citizens has not indicated that Cerio’s departure changes current policies or services. Until the board provides more information, the transition plan remains the next concrete step in a leadership change at a consequential point for the organization.